It’s a tricky question.
Peter Pan has fought off Captain Hook time and time again, even feeding his hand to a crocodile (sheesh)…but how big of a threat is Captain Hook, really? It’s hard to know. Plus, Pan seems to be a bit cocky and not overly serious, which could be a drawback. There’s also the fact that if Peter Pan were to fight Romeo he wouldn’t be able to predict his next move like he can with Captain Hook after having fought him for so long. (But Pan can also fly, so…)
Romeo may also have a bit of an advantage in that he’s clearly trained in sword-fighting. He killed Tybalt, after all (not that I’m proposing a fight-to-the-death sword fight between Peter Pan and Romeo!), and has clearly been in quite a few duels with the Capulets. But he, too, can be a bit rash, and if Peter Pan provokes him by joking too much or something I can see Romeo moving so fast that Peter Pan instantly finds himself cornered.
I’m honestly torn. Who do you think would win? Vote below!
Here are some other questions to ponder: